Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Hotels Food Shopping Coffee Grocery Gas

Arrenello's Pizza

$$

70 reviews

+1 (464) 529-5059

Advertisement

Advertisement

Photos

Cheese curds - small

Thin Crust Pizza

4pc broasted chicken dinner with seasoned potatoes and cole slaw

Award Winning Stuffed Pizza

Best Pizza n NW Indiana!

Brisâtes 2 Piece Box of chicken with a side of cole slaw, bread & broasted potatoes

2556 45th St

Highland, IN 46322

+1 (464) 529-5059

https://www.arrenellos.com

Family owned and operated, your family has been gathering around the table to enjoy our award winning stuffed pizza since 1972. We appreciate & thank you for loving our stuffed for almost 50 years!! That's-some-sweet-sauce!!

Also at this address

Matokar Enterprises-Highland

Find related places

Places To Eat

Fast Food

Pizza

Sandwiches

Restaurants

Reviews

Tim U.

1/19/2025

I've been eating Arrenello's for 33 years (started in Glenwood until I moved to Highland). I claim to be a foodie and am very willing to try all pizza style. Nothing compares. Arrenello's is,...

Read more on Yelp

Michelle M.

3/28/2024

I've ordered from this spot for about two decades. LOVE this spot. The pizza is exceptional. I mean. Really good. However tonight, I had a less than great experience with service. I called at...

Read more on Yelp

Mike T.

2/20/2025

Not a fan at all the sauce is ridiculously sweet. Like I can handle Aurelio's sweet but this pizza is like cheesecake sweet I'll pass next time!

Read more on Yelp

Pam H.

2/1/2025

We moved from Hammond 14 years ago. When we visit we bring a pizza back to our daughter's near St. Louis. The food in NW Indiana is surely missed!!!

Read more on Yelp

Fred M.

12/1/2024

Wonderful pizza. Love the sweet sauce. Always delicious no matter whether the thin crust or deep dish.

Read more on Yelp

Owner verified

See a problem?

You might also like

Little Frank's Pizzeria

Carry-out only (except pizza) restaurant, Pizza restaurants, Eating places

Little Frank's Pizzeria

"Duge here. 6/5 pizza PIE. GET THIS PIE AND SAY GRACE BECAUSE OH MY GOD ITS GOOD. We all have our favorite pizza spots but, this is no little caesers. This is a SERIOUS CHICAGO PIZZA. Heres why:..."

photo of Duge H.

Fabulous Freddies Italian Eatery

Bars and lounges, Eating places, Bar (drinking places)

Fabulous Freddies Italian Eatery

"Been here so many time and always a good experience. Driving through Illinois last time took a two hour detour just to eat the steak sandwich"

photo of Nick M.

Papa Saverio's Pizzeria

Aquariums and zoological gardens, Art gallery, Eating places

Papa Saverio's Pizzeria

"Papa Saverio's Pizzera is an Elgin based chain, so when you are stopping by here you are getting your own taste of Elgin. The one I frequent is on McLean Boulevard. It is chiefly a take out..."

photo of Katherine W.

United States›Indiana›Highland›Arrenello's Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement

Advertisement